- Tell me I did not just see that: Jim Ross balla e vince il dance contest della Michael Cole’s Challenge
- Holy shit moment of the year: Big Show e Mark Henry distruggono in ring a Veangeance dopo un Superplex
- Pipe bomb of the year: CM Punk
- Divalicious moment of the year: Kelly Kelly diventa WWE Divas Champion
- OMG Moment of the year: Triple H esegue una Tombstone su Undertaker a WrestleMania XXVII
- Trending star of the year: Zack Ryder
- Game changer moment of the year: The Rock sfida John Cena a WrestleMania XXVIII
- A-Lister of the year: Snooki
- Superstar of the year: CM Punk
Annunciati su WWE.com
- Outstanding archievement in Muppet resemblance: Sheamus e il suo lontano cugino ritrovato dai capelli rossi Beaker
- Pee-Wee Herman Bowtie Award: David Otunga e il suo abito da affari da Harvard-law-by-way-of-the-Playhouse
- Most predictable outcome of the year: Kevin Nash esegue la powerbomb su Santino Marella
- Return of the year: The Rock
- Double vision moment of the year: Sin Cara vs Sin Cara
- T-Shirt of the year: CM Punk’s “Best in the World”
- WWE.com Exclusive of the year: John Laurinaitis “si congratula” con CM Punk
- Most regrettable ring attire of the year: Michael Cole vestito da Triple H
- Critter moment of the year: Il topolino che passa alle spalle di Alberto Del Rio
- Superstar transformation of the year: Zack Ryder