Anche il secondo titolo della collection dedicata a Silent Hill ha la sua lista obiettivi, ed è strutturalmente piuttosto simile a quella di Silent Hill 3 :Molti argenti e ori, 10 bronzi. Di seguito la lista completa :
Free to GoUnlock the "Leave" ending.
Second BestUnlock the "Maria" ending.
GoodbyeUnlock the "In Water" ending.
Childhood TraumaDefeat Abstract Daddy.
I Don't Need You AnymoreDefeat Pyramid Head.
Where's that Letter!? Defeat Flesh Lips.
Fountain of YouthAcquire the White Chrism.
Not So Lost MemoriesAcquire the book of Lost Memories.
Light ReadingAcquire the book of Crimson Ceremony.
We're Not AloneAcquire the Blue Gem.
Say Your PrayersUnlock the "Rebirth" ending.
It All Makes Sense NowUnlock the "Dog" ending.
Never to be Heard from AgainUnlock the "UFO" ending.
OverkillAcquire the Chainsaw.
Keep Your DistanceDefeat at least 75 enemies by shooting in SH2.
Melee MasterDefeat at least 75 enemies by fighting in SH2.
Keen EyeFind at least 150 items + extra items in SH2.
Don't Keep Her WaitingComplete Boat Stage in less than 1 min 20 seconds.
Hard to HitReceive less than 500 points of damage in one game, in SH2.
Say GoodbyeDefeat Mary.
Restless DreamsUnlock the "Born from a Wish" ending.
Unholy GrailAcquire the Obsidian Goblet.
Warp SpeedComplete SH2 in 3 hours or less.
Who Needs a Gun? Acquire the Green Hyper Spray.
Playing on the EdgeComplete SH2 with 2 saves or less.
I.Q. TestComplete SH2 on Extra Riddle difficulty.
Man's Best FriendAcquire the Dog Key.
She Would Be ProudUnlock all Trophies in SH2.
Pacman
Nostradamus
Magical Cat Adventure
Snake